Music News For You! Accounts
 News
  Interactive
   Collective
    Contact
 

 

now with the highly requested RSS feed.

 
 NY Bar sued over use of unlicensed songs dusty  
 2006-07-28 23:07:12 Yahoo!      
Legal Stuff A bar in New York got sued for using unlicensed songs. The bar didn't put out a CD with music so what did they do wrong?

They allowed guests to sing karaoke to songs that the bar apparently did not llicense on forehand.
In a lawsuit filed last month in U.S. District Court, the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers claimed that the bar violated copyright laws. ASCAP lawyer Michael Sciotti said the bar had plenty of warnings since it opened in 2002.
"There were 27 contacts before it got to me," he said. "We bend over backward to educate businesses and answer questions and most comply voluntarily. Thousands of businesses do it with no problem."
Now using songs illegally is wrong. But if a bar allows the people to sing from a list of 60 songs and only five songs are apparently on the list of not licensed it starting to sound like extortion to me.

Yes they should have paid for those songs. But on the other hand the bar doesn't really make money from the people singing the songs, but it entertains the people. So indirectly the lawsuit is effectively destroying the fun of fans that like to sing those songs.

Read the full article here.

What will the music industry come up with next so they can take fun away from the average music fan?
 
 
  Next Article:Lance Bass' boyfriend happy he came out  
  Previous Article:Last Top Of The Pops details revealed  

 
Article only open for registered members
 
 
 
 


 mirrorball 2006-07-31 11:03:01  

 
Edit Reaction  
Nothing new here. This is what ASCAP has been doing for many years, sending people into bars to see if songs are being played without a license.

If they did contact the bar 27 times, as they claim, then the bar owners should have just removed the five songs from their selection until the issue was resolved, rather than say "well, it's only five songs performed poorly, so what's the big dead?" I agree suing over five songs is a bit tacky, but it sounds like the bar had plenty of warning.

Don't confuse ASCAP with "the music industry." The mp3/file sharing lawsuits are filed by record companies. ASCAP represents the songwriters (aka, the artists), as well as publishers, and it's their job to make sure the songwriters are getting paid for performances of their songs. Heck, since they use a sliding scale, based on the type of performance, I can't imagine the bar was asked to pay that much for a stinkin' karaoke performance. 
 

 Jakmaninov ( Guest ) 2006-08-01 13:10:43  

 
Edit Reaction  
The bars DO make money from those karaoke songs. Did people go into that bar? Did they order drinks? buy food? Then the bar was making money while that song was being sung. Period. 
 
 
Don't mind me, I'm just a guest.
 
 

 dusty ( Website Owner ) 2006-08-01 21:05:54  
Developer
 
Edit Reaction  
Then why isn't there a license needed when they just play the radio with the *SAME* song.

I agree the composer should be getting a fee because their songs might be played, but make it a flat fee for a bar. don't make them license every single song they MIGHT use or might NOT use at some point. 
 
 
For I am the dust!
 
 

 blaze 2006-08-02 10:46:41  

 
Edit Reaction  
ahh, but there is a fee to "just" listen to the radio in a public place! If you don't pay for it, you can't play it. That's what our lawyers found out when a patron complained that we were playing the radio in our public place, for everyone to hear. The radio is for private use only. So if you have the public present, you better be paying for a service (like, gasp, Musak!), or your business can be fined.

Ain't life grand... 
 

 mirrorball 2006-08-02 19:43:06  

 
Edit Reaction  
It's true. ASCAP and BMI, the two songwriters groups, collect licensing fees from bars, restaurants, etc for "performances" for public consumption, which can include radio/tv broadcast. According to ASCAP's definition: "A public performance is one that occurs 'in a place open to the public or at any place where a substantial number of persons outside of a normal circle of a family and its social acquaintances is gathered.'"

As for the licensing fee, it can be a flat fee. It all depends on the bar/restaurant/club, it's revenue, what type of license it needs. For example, a club that hosts live bands most of the week would probably get a flat fee license. But for just one or two shows a year/month, it might be better to get a per concert license. 
 

 Page : 1

 
  This topic is closed for Guest reactions, if you want to react on this article you will have to register  
 
Music News For You!
 Login
Login 
Password 
Create an account
Activate an account
Advertising?
We got the music fans!
 Headlines
Tuesday, 19 Aug 2008
  18:59 Avril Lavigne's Malaysian c ...
  18:43 Gary Glitter released from ...
  18:25 Donnie Wahlberg and wife to ...
  18:10 AC/DC's first album in 8 ye ...
  17:54 Annie Lennox resting after ...
  17:36 Retrial of Phil Spector to ...
Wednesday, 13 Aug 2008
  18:21 Paris Hilton sued for lack ...
  18:03 Jennifer Lopez' Maid in Man ...
  17:47 Mamma Mia soundtrack hits n ...
Tuesday, 12 Aug 2008
  17:55 Former Blink 182 bassist su ...
  17:40 Beatles contract for sale i ...
  17:21 Hank Williams band member dies
  17:05 John Lennon's killer denied ...
  16:30 Britney in talks to appear ...
Monday, 11 Aug 2008
  16:53 U2's music to be destroyed
 Webboard
Sunday, 17 Aug 2008
  10:48 Title of song??
  09:45 Title of song??
Wednesday, 09 Jul 2008
  23:04 For The Members - What Song?
  23:00 Country Music Fans!! PLEA...
Tuesday, 08 Jul 2008
  01:08 Apology to our guests
Wednesday, 02 Jul 2008
  05:36 Apology to our guests
  05:07 Apology to our guests
Wednesday, 11 Jun 2008
  00:42 Nashville Star
Tuesday, 10 Jun 2008
  09:08 Nashville Star
Wednesday, 04 Jun 2008
  16:36 Obama Hillary
  14:00 Obama Hillary
  12:52 Obama Hillary
  09:05 Obama Hillary
  05:56 Obama Hillary
Monday, 02 Jun 2008
  09:00 Indian Idol 4!
 Reactions
Saturday, 09 Aug 2008
   01:03 So You Think You Can Dance ...
   00:50 So You Think You Can Dance ...
Friday, 08 Aug 2008
   12:54 So You Think You Can Dance ...
Thursday, 07 Aug 2008
   23:17 So You Think You Can Dance ...
   00:23 So You Think You Can Dance ...
Wednesday, 06 Aug 2008
   22:47 So You Think You Can Dance ...
Tuesday, 05 Aug 2008
   19:17 More alleged Miley Cyrus ph ...
Monday, 04 Aug 2008
   22:03 Jonas Brothers admit to cel ...
   21:51 Jonas Brothers admit to cel ...
Saturday, 02 Aug 2008
   00:42 So You Think You Can Dance ...
   00:39 So You Think You Can Dance ...
   00:27 So You Think You Can Dance ...
Friday, 01 Aug 2008
   21:42 So You Think You Can Dance ...
   12:29 So You Think You Can Dance ...
Thursday, 31 Jul 2008
   09:53 So You Think You Can Dance ...
   05:31 So You Think You Can Dance ...
   00:20 So You Think You Can Dance ...
Wednesday, 30 Jul 2008
   22:45 So You Think You Can Dance ...
   22:35 So You Think You Can Dance ...
Monday, 28 Jul 2008
   23:39 FCC approves Sirius-XM sate ...
Friday, 25 Jul 2008
   15:37 So You Think You Can Dance ...
   14:59 So You Think You Can Dance ...
Thursday, 24 Jul 2008
   01:29 So You Think You Can Dance ...
Tuesday, 22 Jul 2008
   14:10 DMX arrested after using fa ...
   14:07 Public decides who leaves S ...
 Who's Online?
25 guests online
0 members online
 Spam?
Total: 2759353
Today: 3566
 .PLAN
Thursday, 31 Aug 2006
  17:07 Optimizing SQL
Thursday, 13 Jul 2006
  20:24 Anti-Spamming Part II
  20:02 Spoiler-Tag
Wednesday, 14 Jun 2006
  14:05 RSS Feed
Sunday, 04 Jun 2006
  18:01 News Retrieving
  
 
 
 
Privacy Policy | Advertise
(c) curlio.com 2001-2006